Scott's article raises the legitimate question as where the evolution of college sports will eventually take us.
Clearly football and basketball are examples of college degrees exchanged for playing...actually a legitimized form of pay for play, with the questionable enforced qid pro quo that grades must be maintained. NIL changes this soon to be outmoded and quaint notion that invites a collision between the simultaneous and incompatible goals of sports and NIL business versus academics. As Scott implies, the pursuit of cash poses a potential of distracting the PSA from a full commitment to his sport...and by force... his studies as well.
As Scott argues, the NFL is likely to prop up up the college system in the selfish best interest...but only if it has to. The colleges and their legions of fanatics and well healed padrones will want to keep the dollars fkowing, but a larger share and a smaller NCAA, mainly confined to enforcement of rules dictated by the Power Five.
As for the pesky issue of making grades in the age of NIL, it's not a stretch to consider folding the NIL into a course and degree in NIL Management and Marketing , along with the option for recognized curricula in traditional degrees. The details of course study could be as imaginative as any athlete chooses to operate, including an accounting demonstrating management and profit. Overhead should be fairly allocated as in any business, expensing the value of college provided services.
A primary issue in dealing with NIL is in how to accommodate it in an academic structure, which requires the inconvenience of making grades. Without this, I hardly believe a construct that creates subsidized athletes generating incomes at the expense of state institutions is a result acceptable to the tax paying public
Let's recognize that a professional career in sports is as compelling a reason for a college education as any other professional objective, pulling back the curtain on the de facto truth of it now.
Whether any of this is workable or not remains to be seen. But what is fact, is that some inventive construct is mandatory if we are to preserve what we love best in the college game in the age of NIL, without making a dirty joke of of the meaning if a degree.