The Helfrich era post-mortem
- By HoorayDucks
- First Duck Club
- 4 Replies
Here are the 7 deadly reasons behind Helf's downfall, in order of importance (IMO):
1). A declining defense. Helf made changes on D, but too little, too late. If Helf had fired the current position coaches and brought in a DC with a proven record, he would have gotten another year. He didn't. Last year he hired a first-time DC and just now he chose loyalty over brining in a new defensive staff.
2). The inability to develop a QB. Lockie, Rodriguez, Hobbs, and Mahalak were four consecutive misses at QB (granted, Lockie was Chip's call). If just one of these guys worked out, we would have probably been 11-2 last year and this season would have been viewed as more of an aberration. Helf fixed this problem by brining in three talented young QBs, but not soon enough.
3). Recruiting misses on the defensive side of the ball. Allioti/Pellum/Neal missed on a few DBs like the offensive staff missed on QBs. A few big-time pick-ups in the front 7 didn't pan-out as expected (i.e. Mattingly, Kaumatule, Mafielo). The notion that the coaches were being lazy with recruiting (which has been argued on this site) is laughable. The staff got many guys they went after. Unfortunately, not all of them worked out as planned.
4). On-field discipline. Granted, when the D is on the field for 118 plays (like it was in it's infamous record-setting day against Cal), you can understand a high number of total penalties (more plays = more opportunities for penalties). Still, Helf's squad just had too many of them.
5). Rising expectations from years of success.
6). Recent (and some disturbing) off-field discipline issues (see my post in the thread on Wallace & Franklin).
7). Helf's personality. I think some fans want to listen to an alpha-male in interviews. Helf comes across as indecisive with his combination of stammering and coach-speak. A clearer, more-confident tone would have more convincingly (and accurately) conveyed the plan Helf had in place to get the program back on track.
Consequently, administrators, major boosters, and many every-day fans have decided it's time for a change.
1). A declining defense. Helf made changes on D, but too little, too late. If Helf had fired the current position coaches and brought in a DC with a proven record, he would have gotten another year. He didn't. Last year he hired a first-time DC and just now he chose loyalty over brining in a new defensive staff.
2). The inability to develop a QB. Lockie, Rodriguez, Hobbs, and Mahalak were four consecutive misses at QB (granted, Lockie was Chip's call). If just one of these guys worked out, we would have probably been 11-2 last year and this season would have been viewed as more of an aberration. Helf fixed this problem by brining in three talented young QBs, but not soon enough.
3). Recruiting misses on the defensive side of the ball. Allioti/Pellum/Neal missed on a few DBs like the offensive staff missed on QBs. A few big-time pick-ups in the front 7 didn't pan-out as expected (i.e. Mattingly, Kaumatule, Mafielo). The notion that the coaches were being lazy with recruiting (which has been argued on this site) is laughable. The staff got many guys they went after. Unfortunately, not all of them worked out as planned.
4). On-field discipline. Granted, when the D is on the field for 118 plays (like it was in it's infamous record-setting day against Cal), you can understand a high number of total penalties (more plays = more opportunities for penalties). Still, Helf's squad just had too many of them.
5). Rising expectations from years of success.
6). Recent (and some disturbing) off-field discipline issues (see my post in the thread on Wallace & Franklin).
7). Helf's personality. I think some fans want to listen to an alpha-male in interviews. Helf comes across as indecisive with his combination of stammering and coach-speak. A clearer, more-confident tone would have more convincingly (and accurately) conveyed the plan Helf had in place to get the program back on track.
Consequently, administrators, major boosters, and many every-day fans have decided it's time for a change.