It seems appropriate in these difficult times, and on this Independence Day weekend, to consider the words of our Declaration, which yet remain aspirational and unfulfilled.
In the Preamble, Jefferson wrote: “ We hold these truths as self evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator to certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness.”
We are charged with the understanding that these words are the philosophical basis of our nation, and that the deprivation of these rights compelled our rebellion against a tyranny that withheld them. Yet we are also compelled to consider whether the certainty of the premise was ever true to begin with, given that the author, Jefferson, and many of the signatories, were slave owners. When we do, it is “evident” that the “truths” were contradicted and illusory in actual practice. Consider also that if the words of the Preamble are to command and inform our patriotism, we must finally honor them in our quest for true greatness as a country.
Since July 4th, 1776, we have taken these words for granted, having seldom practiced equality as a nation. The claim of unalienable rights has been contradicted from the beginning, not only by displacing Native Americans, but by slavery and Jim Crow, the denial of women’s sufferage, and investing in wars of expansion, as examples.
Blind patriotism without acknowledging our imperfections is a toxic ignorance that permits a manipulated citizenry whipped into an exclusionary anger while claiming ownership of our Constitution.
Certainly we are at a crossroads again…. challenged again beyond Jefferson... to live up to our promise that so many millions have marched in the streets to oblige us to consider after George Floyd. The falling of symbols of our fictions that we continue to hold dear is an appropriate by- product of our finally coming to an accounting.
We celebrate our founding document in the confidence of its promise, as aspirational and unfulfilled as it remains... because it has guided us in all our imperfections and inspired our Greatest Generation to sacrifice itself in defeating the global threat of a genocidal, racist philosophy. We also, now, can begin to rid ourselves of a persistent vestige of the same. And in doing so, begin to earn the claim to greatness as a country.